Health Insurance Market Share by Company

Medical Loss Ratio: Quarterly Trend

Quarterly medical loss ratio (share of each premium dollar spent on care) for the 6 largest US health insurers. The ACA requires 80-85%; higher means more on care, tighter margins.

UnitedHealth

88.4%Q3 2026

Elevance

90.6%Q3 2026

Cigna

84.5%Q2 2026

Humana

91.1%Q2 2026

Centene

89.6%Q2 2026

Molina

92.9%Q3 2026

Q1 2022 to Q3 2026. Dashed line: 85% ACA floor.

The UnitedHealth Collapse

UnitedHealth (UNH) stock price and forward P/E (price over next-12-month consensus earnings), Jan 2024 to May 2026, through three shocks that erased ~$330B of market cap.

Stock priceMay 2026: $340
Forward P/EMay 2026: 11x
Dec 2024Brian Thompson killed (Dec 4)
Apr 2025Q1 earnings miss + guidance pull (Apr 17)
May 2025Optum DOJ probe disclosed (May 14)
May 2025Trough ~$280
Mar 2026Recovery to ~$340

Medicare Advantage Enrollment by Carrier

Annual Medicare Advantage enrollment by carrier (2020-2026). MA is the private-insurer version of Medicare, where CMS pays insurers a per-member subsidy.

UnitedHealth

9.4M

Humana

7.0M

CVS/Aetna

4.1M

BCBS plans

2.9M

Kaiser

2.0M

Elevance

1.9M

Centene

1.0M

Other

7.2M

February enrollment, 2020 to 2026. Total 35.5M in 2026.

STAR Ratings Distribution

CMS STAR ratings (1 to 5) by Medicare Advantage carrier for 2025; the 4-star-plus share drives bonus payments, and Humana's collapse from 94% to 25% cost about $3B.

CarrierMA Members% in 4-star+ (2024)% in 4-star+ (2025)YoY54.543.53<3
UnitedHealthUNHDropped from 87% to 78%; modest revenue headwind
10.1M87%78%-9pp1518123-
HumanaHUMLost ~$3B in QBP starting 2026; lawsuit filed against CMS; Mar 2025 ruling vacated cut-points but bonuses for 2026 already lost
5.7M94%25%-69pp1361141
CVS/AetnaCVSBest-performing large MA portfolio in 2025; minimal QBP impact
4.3M87%81%-6pp141162-
ElevanceELVFiled lawsuit; 23pp decline
2.2M64%41%-23pp-1594-
CenteneCNCOnly major carrier to improve materially YoY; turnaround under new CEO
1.3M22%55%+33pp-14631
MolinaMOHSmall MA footprint; Medicaid-focused
250K50%35%-15pp--372-
Clover HealthCLOVSmall but high-quality MA portfolio; PPO plan rated 4-star
80K80%90%+10pp-111--
Oscar HealthOSCRACA-marketplace pure-play; exited MA after 2023
----------

Days Claims Payable: Reserve Snapshot

Days Claims Payable, the days of medical claims an insurer could cover from reserves already set aside (healthy range 40-60 days), snapshot at Q1 2026.

DiversifiedACA-focusedMedicaid-focusedMA-focused

Ask Sterling

Register for a premium account to gain access to Sterling AI.

Get Started

Things you can ask Sterling:

Summarize Tesla's latest earnings reportWhy did NVIDIA's margins expand?Compare Apple vs Microsoft's cash flowWhat's driving EV industry growth?
Menu
Favorites
Health Insurance Market Share by Company (2026) | Sterling