Nuclear Fusion
Fusion Approach Comparison
Nine fusion confinement approaches by physics family (magnetic, inertial, magneto-inertial, hybrid), with plasma temperatures, confinement times, and scale-up challenges.
Tokamak
- Typical fuel
- D-T
- Achieved T (million °C)
- 150
- Ignition T (million °C)
- 150
- Confinement time
- 1 to 10+ seconds
- Scale-up challenge
- Plasma disruptions can damage first wall; large size historically required (ITER 6.2 m major radius); HTS magnets unlock smaller scale (SPARC 1.85 m).
- Machines
- ITER, JET, EAST, KSTAR, SPARC
- Companies
- Commonwealth Fusion Systems, Tokamak Energy (spherical variant), Energy Singularity, Open Star Technologies
Stellarator
- Typical fuel
- D-T
- Achieved T (million °C)
- 100
- Ignition T (million °C)
- 150
- Confinement time
- 30+ minutes demonstrated at W7-X
- Scale-up challenge
- 3D-shaped magnetic coils require extreme manufacturing precision; no plasma current means disruption-free steady-state but engineering is harder.
- Machines
- Wendelstein 7-X
- Companies
- Type One Energy, Realta Fusion, Proxima Fusion, Renaissance Fusion
Spherical Tokamak
- Typical fuel
- D-T
- Achieved T (million °C)
- 100
- Ignition T (million °C)
- 150
- Confinement time
- 0.1 to 1 seconds
- Scale-up challenge
- Higher plasma beta in compact geometry but center column engineering and first-wall heat flux are severe.
- Machines
- MAST-U, ST40 (Tokamak Energy), UK STEP (planned)
- Companies
- Tokamak Energy
Field-Reversed Configuration
- Typical fuel
- D-He3 (Helion), p-B11 (TAE target)
- Achieved T (million °C)
- 75
- Ignition T (million °C)
- 500 (D-He3), 1500 (p-B11)
- Confinement time
- milliseconds (pulsed)
- Scale-up challenge
- Pulsed-merger approach (Helion) needs high-repetition-rate switching; beam-heated approach (TAE) struggles to reach p-B11 temperatures.
- Machines
- none listed
- Companies
- Helion Energy (pulsed merged-FRC), TAE Technologies (beam-heated FRC)
Z-Pinch
- Typical fuel
- D-T
- Achieved T (million °C)
- 37
- Ignition T (million °C)
- 150
- Confinement time
- microseconds; seconds-long with sheared-flow stabilization
- Scale-up challenge
- Classical Z-pinch is unstable; sheared-flow stabilization is novel and not yet proven at fusion-relevant conditions.
- Machines
- FuZE-Q (Zap Energy)
- Companies
- Zap Energy
Inertial Confinement Fusion (direct drive)
- Typical fuel
- D-T
- Achieved T (million °C)
- 100
- Ignition T (million °C)
- 100
- Confinement time
- nanoseconds
- Scale-up challenge
- Drivers must run at ~10 Hz for commercial output; NIF runs 1 shot per day. Target fabrication at scale unsolved.
- Machines
- none listed
- Companies
- Focused Energy, Xcimer Energy
Inertial Confinement Fusion (indirect / X-ray drive)
- Typical fuel
- D-T
- Achieved T (million °C)
- 100
- Ignition T (million °C)
- 100
- Confinement time
- nanoseconds
- Scale-up challenge
- Hohlraum target conversion efficiency loss; Q_wall-plug at NIF is ~0.01 even though Q_laser reached 1.5 in Dec 2022.
- Machines
- NIF (LLNL)
- Companies
- Marvel Fusion (short-pulse laser ICF)
Magnetized Target Fusion
- Typical fuel
- D-T
- Achieved T (million °C)
- 10
- Ignition T (million °C)
- 150
- Confinement time
- microseconds
- Scale-up challenge
- Liquid-metal compression liner adds engineering complexity; reaction-vessel survivability unproven.
- Machines
- LM26 (General Fusion)
- Companies
- General Fusion
Hybrid / Pulsed-Power ICF / Other
- Typical fuel
- D-T (Pacific), p-B11 (HB11)
- Achieved T (million °C)
- n/a
- Ignition T (million °C)
- 150 to 1500
- Confinement time
- nanoseconds to microseconds
- Scale-up challenge
- Each hybrid is bespoke. Pacific Fusion uses pulsed-power Z-driven ICF (Sandia heritage); HB11 fires petawatt laser at p-B11 targets; Avalanche uses electrostatic orbitron; classifications overlap with FRC, Z-pinch, and ICF.
- Machines
- none listed
- Companies
- Pacific Fusion (pulsed-power Z-pinch ICF), HB11 Energy (laser-driven p-B11), Avalanche Energy (electrostatic orbitron), First Light Fusion (projectile ICF, now licensing)
| Approach | Confinement | Typical Fuel | Achieved T (million °C) | Ignition T (million °C) | Confinement Time | Scale-up Challenge | Leading Examples |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tokamak | magnetic | D-T | 150 | 150 | 1 to 10+ seconds | Plasma disruptions can damage first wall; large size historically required (ITER 6.2 m major radius); HTS magnets unlock smaller scale (SPARC 1.85 m). |
|
| Stellarator | magnetic | D-T | 100 | 150 | 30+ minutes demonstrated at W7-X | 3D-shaped magnetic coils require extreme manufacturing precision; no plasma current means disruption-free steady-state but engineering is harder. |
|
| Spherical Tokamak | magnetic | D-T | 100 | 150 | 0.1 to 1 seconds | Higher plasma beta in compact geometry but center column engineering and first-wall heat flux are severe. |
|
| Field-Reversed Configuration | magnetic | D-He3 (Helion), p-B11 (TAE target) | 75 | 500 (D-He3), 1500 (p-B11) | milliseconds (pulsed) | Pulsed-merger approach (Helion) needs high-repetition-rate switching; beam-heated approach (TAE) struggles to reach p-B11 temperatures. |
|
| Z-Pinch | magnetic | D-T | 37 | 150 | microseconds; seconds-long with sheared-flow stabilization | Classical Z-pinch is unstable; sheared-flow stabilization is novel and not yet proven at fusion-relevant conditions. |
|
| Inertial Confinement Fusion (direct drive) | inertial | D-T | 100 | 100 | nanoseconds | Drivers must run at ~10 Hz for commercial output; NIF runs 1 shot per day. Target fabrication at scale unsolved. |
|
| Inertial Confinement Fusion (indirect / X-ray drive) | inertial | D-T | 100 | 100 | nanoseconds | Hohlraum target conversion efficiency loss; Q_wall-plug at NIF is ~0.01 even though Q_laser reached 1.5 in Dec 2022. |
|
| Magnetized Target Fusion | magneto-inertial | D-T | 10 | 150 | microseconds | Liquid-metal compression liner adds engineering complexity; reaction-vessel survivability unproven. |
|
| Hybrid / Pulsed-Power ICF / Other | magneto-inertial | D-T (Pacific), p-B11 (HB11) | n/a | 150 to 1500 | nanoseconds to microseconds | Each hybrid is bespoke. Pacific Fusion uses pulsed-power Z-driven ICF (Sandia heritage); HB11 fires petawatt laser at p-B11 targets; Avalanche uses electrostatic orbitron; classifications overlap with FRC, Z-pinch, and ICF. |
|
Fusion Fuel Cycles
Five fusion fuel cycles (D-T, D-D, D-He3, p-B11, p-Li6) compared on ignition temperature, tritium need, neutron output, and global fuel supply.
Tritium supply chokepoint. Global commercial tritium supply is roughly 3 kg per year, almost entirely from CANDU heavy-water reactors at Ontario Power Generation Darlington. Commercial D-T fusion at scale requires self-sustaining tritium breeding (TBR greater than 1.05) from lithium blankets, never demonstrated at burning-plasma conditions. This is the single largest D-T pathway engineering risk.
| Fuel Cycle | Ignition T (MC) | Tritium | Neutron Output | Fuel Availability | Companies Pursuing | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
D-T Deuterium-Tritium | 150 | required | high | Deuterium abundant in seawater (33 g per m3). Tritium is rare: ~3 kg per year of commercial supply globally, primarily from CANDU heavy-water reactors (Ontario Power Generation). Commercial fusion at scale requires self-sustaining tritium breeding from lithium blankets, never demonstrated at scale. | ITER, NIF (LLNL), JET, EAST, +15 more | Default fuel for public programs and most private developers because of lowest ignition temperature. Tritium supply chokepoint is the single largest commercial-fusion bottleneck. |
D-D Deuterium-Deuterium | 400 | not required | moderate | Deuterium abundant in seawater. Eliminates tritium supply dependency. | Helion Energy (intermediate step toward D-He3) | Used by Helion as an intermediate fuel cycle to breed He3 onboard for the D-He3 reaction. Not pursued as a standalone commercial fuel by any major program. |
D-He3 Deuterium-Helium-3 | 500 | not required | low | He3 is rare on Earth (defense-decay stockpile + heavy-water reactor byproduct, kg-per-year scale). Lunar regolith concept exists but is decades from feasibility. Helion plans to breed He3 onboard from D-D side reactions. | Helion Energy | Helion's long-term commercial fuel cycle (Helion FAQ). It runs a mix of deuterium, tritium and helium-3 during testing and operations and breeds helium-3 from D-D side reactions and tritium decay. Reaches usable temperatures at ~500 M-degrees C. The Microsoft agreement (May 10 2023) covers electricity from Helion's first plant, 50 MW or greater after a 1-year ramp-up, expected online by 2028. |
p-B11 Proton-Boron-11 | 1,500 | not required | near-zero | Both fuels abundant. Proton from hydrogen, boron-11 from natural boron (80 percent of natural B). | TAE Technologies, HB11 Energy | Aneutronic fuel cycle. Eliminates tritium supply chokepoint, neutron-activated structure, and most radioactive waste. Required temperatures are 5-10x harder than D-T; no demonstration of net energy at p-B11 conditions to date. |
p-Li6 Proton-Lithium-6 | 1,000 | not required | low | Lithium-6 requires isotopic enrichment; natural Li is 7.5 percent Li-6. | none | Of academic interest as an aneutronic-adjacent fuel cycle. No private company is targeting p-Li6 as the primary commercial fuel as of data cutoff. |
Cross-Cutting Enabling Technologies
Ten enabling-technology categories every commercial fusion plant depends on, with players, suppliers, maturity, and the single gap gating deployment.
Civilian power scope: ten cross-cutting enabling technologies on which any commercial fusion plant depends. Scientific Q (fusion energy out / heating energy in) is the published milestone; engineering Q wall-plug (electricity out / electricity in at the wall) is the harder, less-cited gating metric. Headline gap: REBCO tape, tritium breeding TBR greater than 1, and 10 Hz MJ-class lasers are all unsolved at commercial duty.
Headline enabler
High-Temperature Superconducting (HTS) Magnets
REBCO (rare-earth barium copper oxide) tape conductors operating at 20 K allow compact tokamaks at 20+ tesla. Key enabler for SPARC, ARC, ST40, stellarator commercial scale.
Primary players
Commonwealth Fusion Systems, Tokamak Energy, Type One Energy, Realta Fusion, Proxima Fusion, Energy Singularity
Suppliers / OEMs
Faraday Factory, Bruker, Sumitomo Electric, Fujikura, SuperPower (Furukawa), Shanghai Superconductor
Critical gap
REBCO tape global production capacity is a single-digit-tonnes-per-year industry; CFS plans demand multi-tonne-per-year supply by SPARC commissioning.
Tritium Breeding Blankets
in designLithium-bearing blankets (Li-Pb eutectic or Li-ceramic pebble bed) surround the plasma to breed tritium via neutron capture on Li-6. Demonstrated at lab scale; never at commercial Tritium Breeding Ratio > 1.
Plasma-Facing Materials
in developmentFirst-wall materials must survive 10+ MW per m2 heat flux, 14 MeV neutron bombardment, and tritium retention.
Fusion Development Companies
20 fusion-development companies globally (all private except General Fusion, on Nasdaq since July 2026) targeting civilian grid power, filterable by approach and country. Lifetime funding triangulated from FIA, Crunchbase, and press.
Commonwealth Fusion Systems
Devens, MA, United States
$4,000M
lifetime
- Founded
- 2018
- Fuel
- D-T
- Commercial target
- 2027 (SPARC Q>1), early 2030s (ARC commercial)
TAE Technologies
Foothill Ranch, CA, United States
$1,600M
lifetime
- Founded
- 1998
- Fuel
- p-B11 (target); D-T intermediate
- Commercial target
- Da Vinci first plasma 2029; fusion energy demonstration 2031 (Form S-4/A)
Helion Energy
Everett, WA, United States
$1,500M
lifetime
- Founded
- 2013
- Fuel
- D-He3 (intermediate D-D)
- Commercial target
- Polaris electricity demo: none announced as of 2026-10-08; Orion first plant for Microsoft, initial operations 2028risk
Pacific Fusion
Fremont, CA, United States
$1,000M
lifetime
- Founded
- 2023
- Fuel
- D-T
- Commercial target
- net facility gain by 2030 (Demonstration System)
Proxima Fusion
Munich, Germany
$632M
lifetime
- Founded
- 2023
- Fuel
- D-T
- Commercial target
- Alpha operational in the early 2030s; Stellaris first power plant in the 2030s
General Fusion
Richmond, BC, Canada
$325M
lifetime
- Founded
- 2002
- Fuel
- D-T
- Commercial target
- LM26 milestones by 2028; first-of-a-kind plant around 2035risk
Tokamak Energy
Milton Park, Oxfordshire, United Kingdom
$250M
lifetime
- Founded
- 2009
- Fuel
- D-T
- Commercial target
- pilot plant design only (will not construct it, Aug 2026); UK STEP 2040
Zap Energy
Everett, WA, United States
$200M
lifetime
- Founded
- 2017
- Fuel
- D-T
- Commercial target
- no Q>1 or FOAK date printed; DOE approved the preconceptual pilot plant design May 19 2026
| Company | Country | Founded | Approach | Fuel | Lifetime ($M)▼ | Commercial Target | Investability |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Commonwealth Fusion Systems Devens, MA | United States | 2018 | tokamak | D-T | $4,000 | 2027 (SPARC Q>1), early 2030s (ARC commercial) | private |
TAE Technologies Foothill Ranch, CA | United States | 1998 | FRC | p-B11 (target); D-T intermediate | $1,600 | Da Vinci first plasma 2029; fusion energy demonstration 2031 (Form S-4/A) | private |
Helion Energy Everett, WA | United States | 2013 | FRC | D-He3 (intermediate D-D) | $1,500 | Polaris electricity demo: none announced as of 2026-10-08; Orion first plant for Microsoft, initial operations 2028risk | private |
Pacific Fusion Fremont, CA | United States | 2023 | hybrid | D-T | $1,000 | net facility gain by 2030 (Demonstration System) | private |
Proxima Fusion Munich | Germany | 2023 | stellarator | D-T | $632 | Alpha operational in the early 2030s; Stellaris first power plant in the 2030s | private |
General Fusion Richmond, BC | Canada | 2002 | MTF | D-T | $325 | LM26 milestones by 2028; first-of-a-kind plant around 2035risk | public |
Tokamak Energy Milton Park, Oxfordshire | United Kingdom | 2009 | spherical | D-T | $250 | pilot plant design only (will not construct it, Aug 2026); UK STEP 2040 | private |
Zap Energy Everett, WA | United States | 2017 | Z-pinch | D-T | $200 | no Q>1 or FOAK date printed; DOE approved the preconceptual pilot plant design May 19 2026 | private |
Xcimer Energy Denver, CO | United States | 2022 | ICF (direct) | D-T | $200 | Vulcan by end of 2031; Athena 400 MW by 2035 | private |
Marvel Fusion Munich | Germany | 2019 | ICF (indirect) | D-T (early); p-B11 (long-term) | $183 | ignition by 2032 at the latest; pilot power plant Q_eng above 1 in 2035, net power by 2036 | private |
First Light Fusion Yarnton, Oxfordshire | United Kingdom | 2011 | ICF (indirect) | D-T | $110 | no own power plant; supplies amplifier technology to others | private |
Type One Energy Madison, WI (HQ); Knoxville, TN (operations) | United States | 2022 | stellarator | D-T | $82.4 | Project Infinity full startup by 2034 (Tennessee TDEC, Aug 31 2026) | private |
Energy Singularity Shanghai | China | 2021 | tokamak | D-T | $55 | equivalent Q>2 in 2030 (HH170); power demonstration in 2035 | restricted |
Avalanche Energy Tukwila, WA | United States | 2018 | hybrid | D-D (initial); D-He3 / p-B11 long-term | $50 | no date printed; D-T Q>1 test program at FusionWERX, Richland WA | private |
Realta Fusion Madison, WI | United States | 2022 | stellarator | D-T | $45 | fusion pilot plant mid 2030s; 200 MWe plant with Madison Gas and Electric under evaluation | private |
Open Star Technologies Wellington | New Zealand | 2021 | tokamak | D-T | $30 | demonstrator 2030s | private |
Renaissance Fusion Grenoble | France | 2019 | stellarator | D-T | $24 | fusion electricity in Grenoble in the early 2030s | private |
HB11 Energy Sydney | Australia | 2017 | hybrid | p-B11 | $22 | demonstration 2030s | private |
Focused Energy Darmstadt + Austin TX | Germany / United States | 2021 | ICF (direct) | D-T | $15 | demonstration 2030s | private |
ENN Group fusion Langfang, Hebei | China | 2018 | spherical | p-B11 (target); D-T early | n/a | demonstration 2030s | restricted |
Capital Concentration by Approach
Cumulative private fusion capital by confinement approach: tokamak (CFS) and FRC (TAE, Helion) hold the bulk, with Pacific Fusion alone in the hybrid Z-pinch ICF bucket.
Top 4 capital concentration
78%
$8.10B in Commonwealth Fusion Systems, TAE Technologies, Helion Energy, Pacific Fusion
Commercial Targets vs Sterling Estimates
Per-company fusion milestone targets, with a Sterling estimate (not company-reported) of when each is plausible and a disputed badge where the estimate differs materially.
FIA 2024 survey. 70 percent of the private fusion companies surveyed say fusion will provide electricity to the grid by the end of 2035, and 89 percent by the end of the 2030s. The chart distinguishes scientific Q greater than 1 (the headline milestone) from the FOAK grid plant (the grid-power milestone). The two are typically 6 to 10 years apart in fusion roadmaps.
SPARC (Q greater than 1)
Orion (Malaga WA) (FOAK)
LM26 (demo)
Demonstration System (net facility g...)
HH170 (planned high-field compact HTS tokamak) (Q greater than 1)
Da Vinci (planned 50 MWe prototype power plant) (demo)
Ignition Facility and Neutron Source (location to be confirmed) (ignition)
Infinity Two (400 MWe, Bull Run TN) (FOAK)
Pilot Power Plant (about 100 MW, with Siemens Energy) (pilot)
Athena (400 MW laser fusion power plant) (FOAK)
STEP Fusion, West Burton (UK government programme) (FOAK)
Fusion Company Milestone Burndown
Schedule slip per developer: current commercial target year minus the original target. ITER's first plasma was set for Nov 2019 in its 2010 baseline; its Start of Research Operation is now 2034. Helion still says 2028, now for initial operations. The other developers give ranges, different milestones or no date, so no slip is computed.
| Company | Approach | Next Milestone | Original Target | Current Target | Slip |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Commonwealth Fusion Systems (CFS) | HTS tokamak | SPARC Q > 1 net energy gain demonstration target 2027 | 2030 | early 2030s (ARC, VA) | N/A |
| Helion Energy | FRC magneto-inertial | Polaris D-He3 operation at higher temperatures; Orion plant for the Microsoft PPA target 2028 (Orion, per the Microsoft PPA) | 2028 (Microsoft PPA) | 2028 (Orion; Microsoft agreement, 50 MW or greater) | on schedule |
| TAE Technologies | Field-reversed configuration | Da Vinci first plasma (Copernicus step dropped) target 2029 | 2030 (p-B11 commercial) | 2031 (Da Vinci fusion energy demonstration; initial operations thereafter) | N/A |
| Tokamak Energy | HTS spherical tokamak | HTS magnet system for STEP Fusion (Tokamak Energy is magnet systems partner) target not stated | early 2030s (ST-E1, 2023) | none: pilot plant is design only and Tokamak Energy will not construct it (Aug 18 2026) | N/A |
| Pacific Fusion | Inertial-impulse (pulsed power) | Demonstration System net facility gain target 2030 | not stated | not stated | N/A |
| General Fusion | Magnetized target fusion | LM26 compressional heating to 10 keV target 2028 | 2026 (scientific breakeven, 2023 promise) | around 2035 (first plant) | N/A |
| Zap Energy | Sheared-flow Z-pinch | Fusion pilot plant (no operating date printed) target not stated | not stated | not stated | N/A |
| Marvel Fusion | Inertial laser-driven | Ignition Facility and Neutron Source: ignition target 2032 at the latest | not stated | pilot power plant with Siemens Energy: Q_eng above 1 in 2035, net power by 2036 | N/A |
| First Light Fusion (frozen) | Projectile inertial (paused) | N/A: licensing model, no own plant timeline target N/A | 2030 | Discontinued | N/A |
| ITER (public; 35-country) | Tokamak (D-T) | Start of Research Operation (replaces first plasma in the new baseline) target 2034 | Nov 2019 first plasma (2010 baseline); Dec 2025 per 2016 baseline | 2034 start of research operation; 2039 D-T operations | +15y |
| NIF (LLNL public) | Inertial confinement (lasers) | Production-scale demonstration target N/A (NIF is research, not commercial) | N/A (NIF not commercial) | N/A | N/A |
Annual Fusion Investment 2010-2025
Annual fusion investment by source (private VC, public, and strategic), 2010-2025.
Top 20 Private Fusion Equity Rounds
The largest disclosed private fusion equity rounds, 2019 to 2026, sortable by amount, date, or company. Pacific Fusion's Oct 2024 Series A ($900M) is the largest in fusion history.
Commonwealth Fusion Systems
Series B
$1,800M
2021-12-01
- Post-money
- n/a
- Lead investors
- Tiger Global
- Participants
- Coatue, Bill Gates, Marc Benioff (TIME Ventures), John Doerr, +6
Commonwealth Fusion Systems
Equity round (unnamed)
$1,000M
2026-07-30
- Post-money
- n/a
- Lead investors
- none named
- Participants
- none named
Pacific Fusionrecord
Series A
$900M
2024-10-25
- Post-money
- n/a
- Lead investors
- General Catalyst (Hemant Taneja)
- Participants
- Breakthrough Energy Ventures, Lowercarbon Capital, Lightspeed, Eric Schmidt, +10
Commonwealth Fusion Systems
Series B2
$863M
2025-08-28
- Post-money
- n/a
- Lead investors
- no single lead disclosed; consortium round
- Participants
- NVentures (Nvidia), Google, Counterpoint Global (Morgan Stanley), Stanley Druckenmiller, +8
Helion Energy
Series E
$500M
2021-11-05
- Contingent
- +$1,700M
- Post-money
- n/a
- Lead investors
- Sam Altman
- Participants
- Dustin Moskovitz, Mithril Capital, Capricorn Investment Group
Helion Energy
Series G
$500M
2026-06-04
- Post-money
- $15,500M
- Lead investors
- Thrive Capital
- Participants
- Lux Capital, Peak XV Partners, Lightspeed Venture Partners, SoftBank Vision Fund 2, +7
Helion Energy
Series F
$425M
2025-01-28
- Post-money
- $5,425M
- Lead investors
- none named
- Participants
- Sam Altman, Lightspeed Venture Partners, SoftBank, Mithril Capital, +1
Active Fusion Investors
Active capital allocators with disclosed positions in private fusion companies. Check sizes are shown only where a company release, filing or investor page prints them.
Concentration notes. Broadest portfolio: Lowercarbon Capital with 8 fusion portfolio companies. Unique operator: Sam Altman: led Helion's $500M Series E (Helion, Nov 5 2021).
Lowercarbon Capital
8
companies
- Total fusion
- n/d
- Companies
- Acceleron, Avalanche Energy, Commonwealth Fusion Systems, Pacific Fusion, Renaissance Fusion, Thea Energy, Xcimer Energy, Zap Energy
- Public thesis
- Diversified fusion bet across approaches; betting that one of eight companies will reach commercial pilot scale.
Breakthrough Energy Ventures
5
companies
- Total fusion
- n/d
- Companies
- Commonwealth Fusion Systems, Pacific Fusion, Type One Energy, Xcimer Energy, Zap Energy
- Public thesis
- Climate-stack bets that need to be carbon-negative at gigawatt scale; fusion is the highest-impact electricity bet in BEV's portfolio.
Khosla Ventures
3
companies
- Total fusion
- n/d
- Companies
- Commonwealth Fusion Systems, Realta Fusion, Type One Energy
- Public thesis
- Khosla has stated fusion is the only credible path to base-load clean energy at the scale required for global decarbonization.
Chevron Technology Ventures
2
companies
- Total fusion
- n/d
- Companies
- TAE Technologies, Zap Energy
- Public thesis
- Chevron tech-vc thesis: hydrogen + fusion + carbon-capture portfolio as long-dated optionality alongside core hydrocarbon book.
Google Ventures (GV) and Google
2
companies
- Total fusion
- n/d
- Companies
- TAE Technologies, Commonwealth Fusion Systems
- Public thesis
- Strategic optionality for data center power demand.
Soros Fund Management
2
companies
- Total fusion
- n/d
- Companies
- Commonwealth Fusion Systems, Zap Energy
- Public thesis
- Climate-aligned long-duration bets.
Temasek
2
companies
- Total fusion
- n/d
- Companies
- Commonwealth Fusion Systems, General Fusion
- Public thesis
- Sovereign long-duration clean-energy bet.
Bezos Expeditions
1
company
- Total fusion
- n/d
- Companies
- General Fusion
- Public thesis
- Bezos has publicly framed fusion as a long-term planetary energy bet. General Fusion's May 2025 headcount reduction was a position-risk event for this portfolio; General Fusion listed on Nasdaq (GFUZ) after its business combination closed on Jul 10 2026.
| Investor | Type | Total Fusion ($M) | Portfolio | Companies | Public Thesis |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lowercarbon Capital | venture | n/d | 8 | Acceleron, Avalanche Energy, Commonwealth Fusion Systems, Pacific Fusion, Renaissance Fusion, Thea Energy, Xcimer Energy, Zap Energy | Diversified fusion bet across approaches; betting that one of eight companies will reach commercial pilot scale. |
| Breakthrough Energy Ventures | venture | n/d | 5 | Commonwealth Fusion Systems, Pacific Fusion, Type One Energy, Xcimer Energy, Zap Energy | Climate-stack bets that need to be carbon-negative at gigawatt scale; fusion is the highest-impact electricity bet in BEV's portfolio. |
| Khosla Ventures | venture | n/d | 3 | Commonwealth Fusion Systems, Realta Fusion, Type One Energy | Khosla has stated fusion is the only credible path to base-load clean energy at the scale required for global decarbonization. |
| Chevron Technology Ventures | corporate | n/d | 2 | TAE Technologies, Zap Energy | Chevron tech-vc thesis: hydrogen + fusion + carbon-capture portfolio as long-dated optionality alongside core hydrocarbon book. |
| Google Ventures (GV) and Google | corporate | n/d | 2 | TAE Technologies, Commonwealth Fusion Systems | Strategic optionality for data center power demand. |
| Soros Fund Management | family office | n/d | 2 | Commonwealth Fusion Systems, Zap Energy | Climate-aligned long-duration bets. |
| Temasek | sovereign | n/d | 2 | Commonwealth Fusion Systems, General Fusion | Sovereign long-duration clean-energy bet. |
| Bezos Expeditions | family office | n/d | 1 | General Fusion | Bezos has publicly framed fusion as a long-term planetary energy bet. General Fusion's May 2025 headcount reduction was a position-risk event for this portfolio; General Fusion listed on Nasdaq (GFUZ) after its business combination closed on Jul 10 2026. |
| ENI S.p.A. | corporate | n/d | 1 | Commonwealth Fusion Systems | ENI publicly committed to net-zero by 2050 with fusion as a strategic 2030s-2040s decarbonization play. |
| Founders + executives via Future Ventures (Steve Jurvetson) | venture | n/d | 1 | Commonwealth Fusion Systems | Frontier deep-tech bet. |
| Founders Fund | venture | n/d | 1 | Avalanche Energy | Frontier-physics bets at small check size (Avalanche compact reactor). |
| General Catalyst | venture | n/d | 1 | Pacific Fusion | General Catalyst Health Assurance + climate energy thesis; Pacific Fusion is GC's first fusion bet. |
| Hedosophia | venture | n/d | 1 | Xcimer Energy | Hard-tech moonshot bets across space + energy. |
| Sam Altman (individual) | individual | n/d | 1 | Helion Energy | Altman has stated D-He3 FRC is the fastest path to commercial electricity. Conflict-of-interest considerations: Altman is also CEO of OpenAI, which has electricity demand that could buy Helion output; Microsoft, OpenAI's largest investor, signed first commercial fusion PPA with Helion. |
| TDK Ventures | corporate | n/d | 1 | Type One Energy | Magnetics + power electronics supply chain optionality. |
| Tiger Global Management | venture | n/d | 1 | Commonwealth Fusion Systems | Late-stage crossover positioning; Tiger publicly framed fusion as part of its energy-transition deep-tech mandate before pulling back from frontier-tech in 2022-2023. |
Hyperscaler and Strategic Corporate Bets
Hyperscaler, family-office, and corporate strategic positions in fusion. Microsoft + Helion, Google + CFS and Eni + CFS are the power purchase agreements; the rest are MoUs, equity, or research.
World's first fusion energy purchase agreement
Microsoft + Helion Energy (2023-05-10)
Agreement to provide Microsoft electricity from Helion's first fusion plant, expected online by 2028 and targeting 50 MW or greater after a 1-year ramp-up. Helion calls it the world's first fusion energy purchase agreement; Constellation is power marketer.
Skepticism: Helion has missed previous timeline commitments (its Nov 2021 release targeted a net electricity demonstration in 2024; none has been announced as of Feb 2026). The agreement targets 50 MW or greater after a 1-year ramp-up; Helion's release prints no penalty terms. Physics community skepticism of 2028 delivery is broad. Helion calls it the world's first fusion energy purchase agreement; Google (Jun 30 2025) and Eni (Sep 22 2025) later signed agreements to buy power from CFS's ARC plant.
Fusion PPAs
3
Microsoft + Helion (May 10 2023, 50 MW Washington State, 2028 target), Google + CFS (Jun 30 2025, 200 MW ARC Virginia, early 2030s) and Eni + CFS (Sep 22 2025, ARC Virginia, early 2030s) are the three fusion power purchase agreements. Others are MoU, equity, or research.
Hyperscaler participation
2 / 5
Microsoft (Helion PPA), Google (CFS PPA + CFS + TAE equity + EPFL research). AWS, Meta, Oracle have none.
Hyperscalers absent
3
Amazon Web Services, Meta Platforms, Oracle have no disclosed fusion position. Negative signal vs aggressive fission deal flow.
Sam Altman conflict triangle. Conflict-of-interest tension: Altman is also CEO of OpenAI, which has electricity demand. Microsoft (OpenAI's largest backer and Helion PPA buyer) signed Microsoft + Helion PPA May 2023. Editorial caveat: this triangle is unusually concentrated and warrants disclosure when discussing Helion timelines.
Microsoft
2023-05-10
Partner: Helion Energy
Terms and skepticism in the card above.
2022-02-16
Partner: EPFL Swiss Plasma Center (TCV tokamak)
DeepMind + EPFL Nature paper using reinforcement learning to control plasma shape on TCV tokamak. No equity or PPA. Research collaboration only.
Skepticism: Research only, not a commercial bet. Google's commercial fusion position is the corporate row immediately below (TAE equity + CFS equity + Google CFS 200 MW PPA Jun 30 2025).
Google (corporate)
2022-07-19 (TAE Series G-2); 2025-06-30 (CFS PPA + expanded CFS equity); 2025-08-28 (CFS B2 participation)
Partner: TAE Technologies + Commonwealth Fusion Systems
Google was among the investors in TAE's $250M Series G-2 in Jul 2022, alongside Chevron and Sumitomo. On Jun 30 2025, Google signed a power purchase agreement with CFS for 200 MW for the ARC plant in Chesterfield County, Virginia (early 2030s target) and increased its CFS stake on undisclosed terms. Google has the option to offtake power from additional ARC plants. Google also participated in CFS Series B2 Aug 28 2025.
Skepticism: Google + CFS Jun 30 2025 is the second fusion power purchase agreement (after Microsoft + Helion May 10 2023); Eni signed a third with CFS on Sep 22 2025. CFS prints 'early 2030s' for ARC and no year.
Jeff Bezos (personal, via Bezos Expeditions)
2011 onward
Partner: General Fusion
Bezos invested in General Fusion via Bezos Expeditions starting ~2011 (multiple rounds). Amounts are not disclosed.
Skepticism: Bezos position separate from Amazon Web Services nuclear strategy. General Fusion reduced headcount in May 2025 and listed on Nasdaq (GFUZ) after its business combination closed on Jul 10 2026.
Bill Gates (personal, via Breakthrough Energy Ventures + direct)
2018 onward
Partner: Commonwealth Fusion Systems
Gates was a direct participant in CFS Series B Dec 2021 alongside BEV, an existing CFS investor. Check sizes are not disclosed.
Skepticism: Gates has named CFS as the BEV fusion bet. Gates also funds TerraPower (fission SMR), so fusion is not exclusive bet.
Sam Altman (personal)
2015 onward; led Series E Nov 2021, participated in Series F Jan 2025
Partner: Helion Energy
Altman led Helion's $500M Series E (Nov 5 2021); his involvement as investor and chairman dates to 2015, and he took an expanded role as executive chairman in Nov 2021 (stepped down as chairman 2026-03-23 per Axios). He participated in Series F (Jan 2025) as an existing investor, a round with no named lead. Helion does not disclose his check sizes.
ENI
2018 onward; power purchase agreement Sep 22 2025
Partner: Commonwealth Fusion Systems
Eni has been a CFS shareholder since 2018 and increased its investment in CFS's Series B2; on Sep 22 2025 Eni and CFS announced a power purchase agreement, which the release calls an offtake agreement worth more than $1 billion, for power from the 400 MW ARC plant in Chesterfield County, Virginia (early 2030s); other financial terms were not disclosed. Eni's equity check sizes are not disclosed.
Skepticism: ENI net-zero by 2050 strategy puts fusion in the 2030s-2040s decarbonization path. Eni's 2023 Collaboration Framework Agreement and its Sep 2025 power purchase agreement make it the deepest industrial relationship in fusion.
| Principal | Type | Partner | Nature | Announced | Headline / Skepticism |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Microsoft | hyperscaler | Helion Energy | power purchase agreement | 2023-05-10 | Agreement to provide Microsoft electricity from Helion's first fusion plant, expected online by 2028 and targeting 50 MW or greater after a 1-year ramp-up. Helion calls it the world's first fusion energy purchase agreement; Constellation is power marketer. Skepticism: Helion has missed previous timeline commitments (its Nov 2021 release targeted a net electricity demonstration in 2024; none has been announced as of Feb 2026). The agreement targets 50 MW or greater after a 1-year ramp-up; Helion's release prints no penalty terms. Physics community skepticism of 2028 delivery is broad. Helion calls it the world's first fusion energy purchase agreement; Google (Jun 30 2025) and Eni (Sep 22 2025) later signed agreements to buy power from CFS's ARC plant. |
| hyperscaler | EPFL Swiss Plasma Center (TCV tokamak) | research collaboration | 2022-02-16 | DeepMind + EPFL Nature paper using reinforcement learning to control plasma shape on TCV tokamak. No equity or PPA. Research collaboration only. Skepticism: Research only, not a commercial bet. Google's commercial fusion position is the corporate row immediately below (TAE equity + CFS equity + Google CFS 200 MW PPA Jun 30 2025). | |
| Google (corporate) | hyperscaler | TAE Technologies + Commonwealth Fusion Systems | equity (TAE + CFS) + 200 MW ... | 2022-07-19 (TAE Series G-2); 2025-06-30 (CFS PPA + expanded CFS equity); 2025-08-28 (CFS B2 participation) | Google was among the investors in TAE's $250M Series G-2 in Jul 2022, alongside Chevron and Sumitomo. On Jun 30 2025, Google signed a power purchase agreement with CFS for 200 MW for the ARC plant in Chesterfield County, Virginia (early 2030s target) and increased its CFS stake on undisclosed terms. Google has the option to offtake power from additional ARC plants. Google also participated in CFS Series B2 Aug 28 2025. Skepticism: Google + CFS Jun 30 2025 is the second fusion power purchase agreement (after Microsoft + Helion May 10 2023); Eni signed a third with CFS on Sep 22 2025. CFS prints 'early 2030s' for ARC and no year. |
| Amazon Web Services | hyperscaler | none | none disclosed | n/a | AWS has no disclosed fusion position as of data cutoff. All Amazon nuclear bets (Talen, X-energy, Energy Northwest, Dominion) are fission. Amazon strategy appears to be early-commercial advanced fission rather than fusion optionality. Skepticism: Negative signal: AWS has been most aggressive hyperscaler on nuclear but explicitly chose fission. Worth tracking whether AWS adds fusion position in 2026-2027. |
| Meta Platforms | hyperscaler | none | none disclosed | n/a | Meta has no disclosed fusion position. Constellation Clinton PPA Jun 2025 is fission. No public fusion strategy. Skepticism: Negative signal. Meta clean-energy strategy is renewables + fission existing fleet. |
| Oracle | hyperscaler | none | none disclosed | n/a | Oracle SMR commentary (Sep 2024 + Sep 2025 earnings calls) references fission SMRs, not fusion. No fusion position disclosed. |
| Jeff Bezos (personal, via Bezos Expeditions) | individual / family ... | General Fusion | equity (multiple rounds) | 2011 onward | Bezos invested in General Fusion via Bezos Expeditions starting ~2011 (multiple rounds). Amounts are not disclosed. Skepticism: Bezos position separate from Amazon Web Services nuclear strategy. General Fusion reduced headcount in May 2025 and listed on Nasdaq (GFUZ) after its business combination closed on Jul 10 2026. |
| Bill Gates (personal, via Breakthrough Energy Ventures + direct) | individual / family ... | Commonwealth Fusion Systems | equity (BEV lead + direct) | 2018 onward | Gates was a direct participant in CFS Series B Dec 2021 alongside BEV, an existing CFS investor. Check sizes are not disclosed. Skepticism: Gates has named CFS as the BEV fusion bet. Gates also funds TerraPower (fission SMR), so fusion is not exclusive bet. |
| Sam Altman (personal) | individual (operator... | Helion Energy | Chairman since 2015 + lead i... | 2015 onward; led Series E Nov 2021, participated in Series F Jan 2025 | Altman led Helion's $500M Series E (Nov 5 2021); his involvement as investor and chairman dates to 2015, and he took an expanded role as executive chairman in Nov 2021 (stepped down as chairman 2026-03-23 per Axios). He participated in Series F (Jan 2025) as an existing investor, a round with no named lead. Helion does not disclose his check sizes. Skepticism: Conflict-of-interest tension: Altman is also CEO of OpenAI, which has electricity demand. Microsoft (OpenAI's largest backer and Helion PPA buyer) signed Microsoft + Helion PPA May 2023. Editorial caveat: this triangle is unusually concentrated and warrants disclosure when discussing Helion timelines. |
| ENI | corporate strategic ... | Commonwealth Fusion Systems | equity + power purchase agre... | 2018 onward; power purchase agreement Sep 22 2025 | Eni has been a CFS shareholder since 2018 and increased its investment in CFS's Series B2; on Sep 22 2025 Eni and CFS announced a power purchase agreement, which the release calls an offtake agreement worth more than $1 billion, for power from the 400 MW ARC plant in Chesterfield County, Virginia (early 2030s); other financial terms were not disclosed. Eni's equity check sizes are not disclosed. Skepticism: ENI net-zero by 2050 strategy puts fusion in the 2030s-2040s decarbonization path. Eni's 2023 Collaboration Framework Agreement and its Sep 2025 power purchase agreement make it the deepest industrial relationship in fusion. |
| TVA (Tennessee Valley Authority) | utility (US federal) | Type One Energy | MoU + site host designation | 2023-05 | TVA + Type One Energy MoU May 2023 designating Bull Run TN as host site for Infinity One fusion plant. TVA is a US federal utility; this is the most concrete utility-developer partnership in fusion. Not a PPA. Skepticism: MoU only, FOAK target early 2030s. TVA Bull Run is a retired coal plant site offering grid connection and water access. Site-host designation is unusual depth for an MoU. |
| Chevron Technology Ventures | corporate strategic ... | TAE Technologies + Zap Energy | equity | 2014 (TAE) onward; Zap Series D Jul 2024 | Chevron Technology Ventures was among the investors in TAE's $250M Series G-2 in Jul 2022; participated in Zap Energy Series D Jul 2024. Check sizes are not disclosed. Skepticism: Strategic R&D positioning, not industrial alliance scale of ENI + CFS. |
Scientific Milestones Timeline
Major fusion milestones 1991-2025, from JET's 16.1 MW pulse to NIF's 2022 ignition and 2023 long-duration plasmas. NIF's Q is laser-basis, not wall-plug.
1991
JET (Joint European Torus) First DT plasma in tokamak (preliminary tritium experiment)
1.7 MW peak fusion power, 2-second pulse; Q_thermal ~0.12
1997
JET 16.1 MW peak DT fusion power, record stood 25 years
16.1 MW peak; 21.7 MJ total energy over 5 seconds; Q_thermal 0.67
2009
NIF (National Ignition Facility) First operation; 192-beam 1.8 MJ UV laser system commissioned
1.8 MJ laser energy at 351 nm; target chamber 10 m diameter
2014
NIF Fuel gain greater than 1 (alpha-particle self-heating)
17 kJ fusion yield; alpha-particle deposition exceeded radiative losses; fuel-gain >1 (excludes hohlraum + laser conversion losses)
2015
Wendelstein 7-X First plasma in world's largest stellarator
First helium plasma Dec 10 2015; first hydrogen plasma Feb 2016
2021
Helion Trenta 100 million degree C ion temperature in FRC
100 M-degree C; pulsed FRC merger configuration
NIF Burning plasma regime achieved
1.3 MJ fusion yield on Aug 8 2021 shot; alpha-particle heating dominant; Q_laser ~0.7
SPARC TFMC (CFS + MIT) 20 Tesla HTS magnet field test (Toroidal Field Model Coil)
20 T peak field on a fusion-relevant scale coil
2022
JET 59 MJ DT fusion energy over a five-second pulse
Pulse #99971: 59 MJ total fusion energy over 5 s; ~11 MW average fusion power; Q_thermal ~0.33; more than doubled the 1997 record of 22 MJ
ST40 (Tokamak Energy) 100 million degree C ion temperature in compact spherical tokamak
100 M-degree C in ST40 (small spherical tokamak)
NIF Ignition: fusion energy out exceeds laser energy in (Q_laser > 1)
3.15 MJ fusion yield from 2.05 MJ laser energy on Dec 5 2022; Q_laser = 1.54
2023
Wendelstein 7-X 8-minute steady-state plasma in stellarator with 1.3 GJ energy turnover
Feb 15 2023 shot: 8-minute power plasma with 1.3 gigajoule energy turnover; current world stellarator record
EAST 403 seconds steady-state plasma (high-confinement mode)
403 s plasma duration in H-mode on Apr 12 2023
JT-60SA First plasma in world's largest operational superconducting tokamak
First plasma Oct 23 2023; design target H-mode plasma 100s
NIF Multiple repeats of ignition; higher-yield shot 3.88 MJ
Jul 30 2023 shot: 3.88 MJ fusion yield from 2.05 MJ laser; Q_laser 1.89; Q_wall-plug still ~0.01
2024
KSTAR 100 million degree C ion temperature sustained for 48 seconds; H-mode held over 100 seconds
100 M-degree C ion temperature for 48 s; H-mode for over 100 s (campaign Dec 2023 to Feb 2024, first after upgrading the divertors to tungsten)
NIF Estimated 5.2 MJ yield on Feb 12 2024
Estimated 5.2 MJ fusion yield from 2.2 MJ laser; Q_laser ~2.4; Q_wall-plug still ~0.02
Energy Singularity HH70 First HTS tokamak first plasma outside CFS
HH70 first plasma Jun 2024; superconducting tokamak with HTS coils
2025
General Fusion LM26 First plasma in the LM26 magnetized target fusion demonstration machine
LM26 first plasma announced Mar 11 2025
EAST 1,066 seconds steady-state H-mode plasma at nearly 70 M-degree C
Jan 20 2025 shot #150425: 1,066 s plasma in H-mode at nearly 70 M-degree C, broke EAST's 2023 403s record
CFS SPARC SPARC construction milestones; commissioning progress
Major-radius 1.85 m machine; HTS magnet integration
Critical Q distinction. NIF Dec 5 2022 ignition is Q_laser (3.15 MJ fusion from 2.05 MJ laser), not Q_wall-plug. Q_wall-plug at NIF is ~0.01 because lasers run ~1 percent wall-plug efficient (300 MJ grid for one 2.05 MJ pulse). JET Q_thermal 0.67 (1997) is the highest sustained MCF Q. ITER targets Q_thermal = 10. Commercial fusion requires Q_wall-plug greater than ~3.
Public Mega-Programs
Public fusion mega-programs (international, national, and regional), with construction start, funding, and revised schedules.
ITER publishes no single-currency cost total. Its FAQ cites about EUR 13B for the original construction across the seven Members and EUR 4B added by the 2016 baseline; Baseline 2024 adds EUR 5B for the ITER Organization, under review. ITER is a research facility, not a power plant: it produces zero grid electricity.
Intergovernmental2 programs
JT-60SA
$1B
funding
- Host
- QST Naka, Japan (EU-Japan Broader Approach)
- Approach
- MCF superconducting tokamak (ITER-class)
- Construction start
- 2007
- Revised schedule
- Operating; commissioning ongoing 2024-2025
- Status
- World's largest operational superconducting tokamak (until ITER)
ITER
n/d
no USD total
- Host
- Cadarache, France (international consortium of 34 countries)
- Approach
- MCF tokamak (D-T capable)
- Construction start
- 2010
- Revised schedule
- Baseline 2024 (approach endorsed by the ITER Council, Nov 2024): Start of Research Operation (H + D-D plasmas) 2034; full magnetic energy 2036; DT operation 2039
- Status
- Construction ongoing; cryostat complete; vacuum vessel sector assembly in progress, six of nine sector modules in the pit (Jul 2026)
| Program | Host | Approach | Constr. start | Revised schedule | Funding ($B) | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
JT-60SA not a power plant | QST Naka, Japan (EU-Japan Broader Approach) | MCF superconducting tokamak (ITER-class) | 2007 | Operating; commissioning ongoing 2024-2025 | 1 | World's largest operational superconducting tokamak (until ITER) |
ITER not a power plant | Cadarache, France (international consortium of 34 countries) | MCF tokamak (D-T capable) | 2010 | Baseline 2024 (approach endorsed by the ITER Council, Nov 2024): Start of Research Operation (H + D-D plasmas) 2034; full magnetic energy 2036; DT operation 2039 | n/d | Construction ongoing; cryostat complete; vacuum vessel sector assembly in progress, six of nine sector modules in the pit (Jul 2026) |
EU and UK2 programs
DEMO (EUROfusion)
$500M
funding
- Host
- EU EUROfusion consortium
- Approach
- MCF tokamak (D-T capable, commercial demonstrator)
- Construction start
- design phase
- Revised schedule
- Roadmap reviewed periodically; 2050+ commercial demonstration target
- Status
- Pre-conceptual design; awaits ITER operational results
UK STEP (Spherical Tokamak for Energy Production)
$300M
funding
- Host
- UKAEA, West Burton, UK
- Approach
- MCF spherical tokamak (D-T capable, commercial prototype)
- Construction start
- 2027
- Revised schedule
- £220M committed for the first phase, with a concept design by 2024 (GOV.UK, Oct 3 2022)
- Status
- Concept design phase; Tokamak Energy named magnet systems partner under a £70M UK Fusion Energy contract to March 2029 (Tokamak Energy, Apr 14 2026)
| Program | Host | Approach | Constr. start | Revised schedule | Funding ($B) | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
DEMO (EUROfusion) commercial-prototype target | EU EUROfusion consortium | MCF tokamak (D-T capable, commercial demonstrator) | design phase | Roadmap reviewed periodically; 2050+ commercial demonstration target | 0.5 | Pre-conceptual design; awaits ITER operational results |
UK STEP (Spherical Tokamak for Energy Production) commercial-prototype target | UKAEA, West Burton, UK | MCF spherical tokamak (D-T capable, commercial prototype) | 2027 | £220M committed for the first phase, with a concept design by 2024 (GOV.UK, Oct 3 2022) | 0.3 | Concept design phase; Tokamak Energy named magnet systems partner under a £70M UK Fusion Energy contract to March 2029 (Tokamak Energy, Apr 14 2026) |
National8 programs
CFETR (China Fusion Engineering Test Reactor)
$6B
funding
- Host
- China Academy of Sciences IPP
- Approach
- MCF tokamak (D-T capable, commercial demonstrator)
- Construction start
- design phase
- Revised schedule
- Roadmap reviewed in 14th + 15th Five-Year Plans
- Status
- Engineering design phase; CN partner of ITER and post-ITER bridge to commercial
JET (Joint European Torus)
$4.5B
funding
- Host
- Culham, UK (decommissioned Dec 2023)
- Approach
- MCF tokamak (D-T capable)
- Construction start
- 1978
- Revised schedule
- Decommissioned Dec 2023 after JET DT-2 campaign; final DT operation completed
- Status
- Decommissioning underway; data and methodology informing ITER + UK STEP
NIF (National Ignition Facility)
$3.5B
funding
- Host
- Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, US
- Approach
- ICF indirect drive (X-ray drive, 192 laser beams)
- Construction start
- 1997
- Revised schedule
- Mission complete on ignition basis; current research phase optimizes yield + reproducibility
- Status
- Operating since 2009; ignition achieved Dec 2022; peak yield 5.2 MJ Feb 2024
Wendelstein 7-X
$1.5B
funding
- Host
- IPP Greifswald, Germany
- Approach
- MCF stellarator (quasi-isodynamic)
- Construction start
- 1996
- Revised schedule
- Ongoing operations; not D-T capable (deuterium-only)
- Status
- Operational; longest hot plasma in any fusion machine
| Program | Host | Approach | Constr. start | Revised schedule | Funding ($B) | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
CFETR (China Fusion Engineering Test Reactor) commercial-prototype target | China Academy of Sciences IPP | MCF tokamak (D-T capable, commercial demonstrator) | design phase | Roadmap reviewed in 14th + 15th Five-Year Plans | 6 | Engineering design phase; CN partner of ITER and post-ITER bridge to commercial |
JET (Joint European Torus) not a power plant | Culham, UK (decommissioned Dec 2023) | MCF tokamak (D-T capable) | 1978 | Decommissioned Dec 2023 after JET DT-2 campaign; final DT operation completed | 4.5 | Decommissioning underway; data and methodology informing ITER + UK STEP |
NIF (National Ignition Facility) not a power plant | Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, US | ICF indirect drive (X-ray drive, 192 laser beams) | 1997 | Mission complete on ignition basis; current research phase optimizes yield + reproducibility | 3.5 | Operating since 2009; ignition achieved Dec 2022; peak yield 5.2 MJ Feb 2024 |
Wendelstein 7-X not a power plant | IPP Greifswald, Germany | MCF stellarator (quasi-isodynamic) | 1996 | Ongoing operations; not D-T capable (deuterium-only) | 1.5 | Operational; longest hot plasma in any fusion machine |
EAST not a power plant | Hefei IPP, Chinese Academy of Sciences | MCF superconducting tokamak | 2003 | Ongoing operations; 403s plasma Apr 12 2023 record; 1,066s H-mode plasma Jan 20 2025 (subsequently surpassed by WEST 1,336s Feb 18 2025) | 0.4 | Operational; produces sustained-plasma records |
KSTAR not a power plant | KFE Daejeon, South Korea | MCF superconducting tokamak | 1995 | Ongoing operations; 300s plasma target | 0.35 | Operational; tungsten divertor upgrade enabled higher-temperature plasmas |
HL-3 (formerly HL-2M) not a power plant | Southwestern Institute of Physics (SWIP), Chengdu, China | MCF tokamak | 2009 | Operating | 0.2 | Operational; supports China CFETR design |
DOE Milestone-Based Fusion Development Program commercial-prototype target | US Department of Energy + 8 private companies | Mixed (technology-agnostic) | 2023 | On schedule | 0.046 | 8 companies receiving milestone-based grants; ARPA-E + DOE oversight |
ITER Status Tracker
ITER milestone tracker, 2007 to Baseline 2024. First plasma was set for Nov 2019 in the 2010 baseline; research operations now start in 2034 and deuterium-tritium fuel in 2039. ITER produces no grid electricity by design.
ITER is NOT a power plant. It produces zero grid electricity. ITER is a research facility designed to demonstrate Q_thermal = 10 sustained for 400 seconds at 500 MW thermal output. Q_thermal is fusion power vs plasma-heating power, not vs grid input. Post-ITER, a commercial demonstrator (EUROfusion DEMO, planned 2050s+) would add a thermal-to-electric system, tritium breeding blanket, and steady-state operation.
Cryostat base
installed
1,250 tonnes, May 2020
Research operation
2034
15-year slip vs Nov 2019 first plasma
DT operation
2039
deuterium-tritium
Cost range
$25-65B
member-assessed vs DOE life-cycle
First-plasma forecast, 2010 baseline to Nov 2024
| Review | First plasma forecast | DT operation forecast |
|---|---|---|
| 2010-07 | Nov 2019 | Mar 2027 (2026 if possible) |
| 2016-11 | Dec 2025 | 2035 |
| 2024-11 | 2034 (Start of Research Operation, H + D-D) | 2039 |
Construction site preparation
complete- Original
- 2007-2009
- Nov 2024
- complete 2009
Preparatory works ran from 2007 to 2009: about 90 hectares cleared, then the 42-hectare platform levelled. On-site construction of the scientific facility began in 2010 (ITER).
Tokamak Complex building
complete- Original
- 2017
- Nov 2024
- complete 2023
Tritium, Tokamak and Diagnostic buildings, seven storeys. The Tokamak Building was transferred to the ITER Organization in Mar 2020 for machine assembly; the Tritium Building, the last civil works, was completed in late 2023 (ITER). Not confirmed in a primary source as of 2026-11-01: the original target year.
Cryostat base installation
complete- Original
- 2019
- Nov 2024
- complete May 2020
The 1,250-tonne cryostat base, the heaviest single component, was installed in the tokamak pit in May 2020; the cryostat lid is the last step of tokamak assembly (ITER). Not confirmed in a primary source as of 2026-11-01: the original target year.
Vacuum vessel sector assembly
in progress- Original
- 2020-2022
- Nov 2024
- in progress, six of nine sector modules in the pit; final module mid-2027
Nine vacuum vessel sectors (four from Korea, five from Europe), each joined with thermal shield panels and two toroidal field coils into a sector module. Module #7 went into the pit on 10 Apr 2025 and the sixth module on 28 Jul 2026; ITER expects the final module in mid-2027 (ITER, 29 Jul 2026). Not confirmed in a primary source as of 2026-11-01: the original target year.
Tokamak first sector installation
complete- Original
- 2021
- Nov 2024
- May 2022; removed Jul 2023; re-installed Apr 2025
Sector module #6 was lowered into the pit on 11 May 2022 and removed on 5 Jul 2023 for repairs to the vacuum vessel sector and thermal shield; module #7 went into the pit on 10 Apr 2025 and #6 returned in Jun 2025 (ITER). Not confirmed in a primary source as of 2026-11-01: the original target year.
Toroidal field coils delivery
complete- Original
- 2020-2021
- Nov 2024
- complete Dec 2023
19 toroidal field coils (18 plus one spare), 10 from Europe and 9 from Japan, shipped from Apr 2020; the last arrived on 15 Dec 2023 (ITER). Not confirmed in a primary source as of 2026-11-01: the original target year.
Cooling water system
in progress- Original
- 2023
- Nov 2024
- in progress
First-phase plant assembly covers the cooling water plant. In the Tokamak Complex, an 11-metre bridge carrying 28 process pipes for the tokamak cooling water system was completed on 30 Aug 2026 (ITER). Not confirmed in a primary source as of 2026-11-01: the original target year and a completion year.
Start of Research Operation (hydrogen + D-D plasmas)
delayed- Original
- Nov 2019 (first plasma)
- Nov 2024
- 2034+15 yr
ITER Council baselines set First Plasma for Nov 2019 (Jul 2010) and Dec 2025 (2016 baseline). Baseline 2024 replaces it with Start of Research Operation (hydrogen and D-D plasmas) in 2034, followed by 27 months of research. ITER describes the 2016 First Plasma as a brief, low-energy machine test, so the 15-year slip compares different gates.
Full magnetic energy
delayed- Original
- 2033 (per 2016 reference plan)
- Nov 2024
- 2036+3 yr
Baseline 2024 targets full magnetic energy in 2036, a 3-year delay vs the 2016 reference plan (ITER, 3 Jul 2024).
Deuterium-tritium operation
delayed- Original
- 2035
- Nov 2024
- 2039+4 yr
Baseline 2024 puts the start of the deuterium-tritium operation phase in 2039, a 4-year delay vs the 2035 of the 2016 baseline (ITER, 3 Jul 2024).
Full deuterium-tritium baseline performance (Q_thermal = 10)
delayed- Original
- n/a
- Nov 2024
- after the 2039 DT start
Q_thermal = 10 means 500 MW of fusion power from 50 MW of plasma heating in 400-second pulses, not Q_wall-plug; it still does not feed the grid. Not confirmed in a primary source as of 2026-11-01: a target year for Q_thermal = 10; ITER prints the goal and 2039 as the start of DT operation.
| Milestone | Original | Nov 2024 revised | Status | Slip (yr) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Construction site preparation | 2007-2009 | complete 2009 | complete | . | Preparatory works ran from 2007 to 2009: about 90 hectares cleared, then the 42-hectare platform levelled. On-site construction of the scientific facility began in 2010 (ITER). |
| Tokamak Complex building | 2017 | complete 2023 | complete | . | Tritium, Tokamak and Diagnostic buildings, seven storeys. The Tokamak Building was transferred to the ITER Organization in Mar 2020 for machine assembly; the Tritium Building, the last civil works, was completed in late 2023 (ITER). Not confirmed in a primary source as of 2026-11-01: the original target year. |
| Cryostat base installation | 2019 | complete May 2020 | complete | . | The 1,250-tonne cryostat base, the heaviest single component, was installed in the tokamak pit in May 2020; the cryostat lid is the last step of tokamak assembly (ITER). Not confirmed in a primary source as of 2026-11-01: the original target year. |
| Vacuum vessel sector assembly | 2020-2022 | in progress, six of nine sector modules in the pit; final module mid-2027 | in progress | . | Nine vacuum vessel sectors (four from Korea, five from Europe), each joined with thermal shield panels and two toroidal field coils into a sector module. Module #7 went into the pit on 10 Apr 2025 and the sixth module on 28 Jul 2026; ITER expects the final module in mid-2027 (ITER, 29 Jul 2026). Not confirmed in a primary source as of 2026-11-01: the original target year. |
| Tokamak first sector installation | 2021 | May 2022; removed Jul 2023; re-installed Apr 2025 | complete | . | Sector module #6 was lowered into the pit on 11 May 2022 and removed on 5 Jul 2023 for repairs to the vacuum vessel sector and thermal shield; module #7 went into the pit on 10 Apr 2025 and #6 returned in Jun 2025 (ITER). Not confirmed in a primary source as of 2026-11-01: the original target year. |
| Toroidal field coils delivery | 2020-2021 | complete Dec 2023 | complete | . | 19 toroidal field coils (18 plus one spare), 10 from Europe and 9 from Japan, shipped from Apr 2020; the last arrived on 15 Dec 2023 (ITER). Not confirmed in a primary source as of 2026-11-01: the original target year. |
| Cooling water system | 2023 | in progress | in progress | . | First-phase plant assembly covers the cooling water plant. In the Tokamak Complex, an 11-metre bridge carrying 28 process pipes for the tokamak cooling water system was completed on 30 Aug 2026 (ITER). Not confirmed in a primary source as of 2026-11-01: the original target year and a completion year. |
| Start of Research Operation (hydrogen + D-D plasmas) | Nov 2019 (first plasma) | 2034 | delayed | 15 | ITER Council baselines set First Plasma for Nov 2019 (Jul 2010) and Dec 2025 (2016 baseline). Baseline 2024 replaces it with Start of Research Operation (hydrogen and D-D plasmas) in 2034, followed by 27 months of research. ITER describes the 2016 First Plasma as a brief, low-energy machine test, so the 15-year slip compares different gates. |
| Full magnetic energy | 2033 (per 2016 reference plan) | 2036 | delayed | 3 | Baseline 2024 targets full magnetic energy in 2036, a 3-year delay vs the 2016 reference plan (ITER, 3 Jul 2024). |
| Deuterium-tritium operation | 2035 | 2039 | delayed | 4 | Baseline 2024 puts the start of the deuterium-tritium operation phase in 2039, a 4-year delay vs the 2035 of the 2016 baseline (ITER, 3 Jul 2024). |
| Full deuterium-tritium baseline performance (Q_thermal = 10) | n/a | after the 2039 DT start | delayed | . | Q_thermal = 10 means 500 MW of fusion power from 50 MW of plasma heating in 400-second pulses, not Q_wall-plug; it still does not feed the grid. Not confirmed in a primary source as of 2026-11-01: a target year for Q_thermal = 10; ITER prints the goal and 2039 as the start of DT operation. |
NIF Yield History
NIF fusion yield per shot (MJ), 2009-2026. Dec 2022 ignition hit 3.15 MJ out from 2.05 MJ laser in (Q_laser 1.54); the Apr 2025 record is 8.6 MJ. Q_wall-plug stays near 0.01.
- 1Burning plasma achieved (1.3 MJ)
- 2First ignition (3.15 MJ, Q_laser 1.54)
- 3Ignition reproduced (3.88 MJ)
- 4Peak yield 8.6 MJ
Q_laser is not Q_wall-plug. Q_laser is fusion-energy-out / laser-energy-in. Q_laser > 1 was achieved Dec 5 2022 with 3.15 MJ / 2.05 MJ = 1.54. Q_wall-plug is fusion-energy-out / grid-electricity-in. NIF requires ~300 MJ of grid electricity to deliver a 2.05 MJ laser pulse, because excimer/Nd:glass laser wall-plug efficiency is ~1 percent. Therefore Q_wall-plug at NIF Dec 2022 was 3.15 / 300 ~ 0.01. Commercial fusion requires Q_wall-plug > ~3 after accounting for thermal-to-electric conversion (~40 percent efficient) and recirculating power. NIF is 300x below commercial threshold on wall-plug basis. NIF shot rate is ~1 shot per day with extensive between-shot target swap and laser-system reset. Commercial ICF requires ~10 Hz (~10 shots per second) sustained, never demonstrated.
Regulatory Framework by Country
How 10 country and region jurisdictions regulate commercial fusion, anchored by the US NRC 2023 light-touch ruling (10 CFR Part 30, not the fission Part 50/52).
US NRC Apr 13 2023 (key precedent). The NRC Commission directed staff to regulate fusion energy machines under the 10 CFR Part 30 byproduct material framework, NOT Part 50/52 (utilization facility, the fission framework). The ADVANCE Act (Jul 9 2024, s.205) then wrote fusion machines into the Atomic Energy Act definition of byproduct material. The NRC fusion machines rule was only proposed on Feb 26 2026 (comments closed May 27 2026) and is not final; the statutory deadline is Dec 31 2027. So far: no NRC reactor license under Part 50/52, and Agreement States oversee byproduct material. The UK (Energy Act 2023, s.156) keeps fusion outside nuclear site licensing, and Japan applies its radioisotope law for the time being.
| Country | Regulator | Current framework | Key decision | Status | Implications |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
United States key precedent | Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) | 10 CFR Part 30 byproduct material framework (fusion machines); ADVANCE Act s.205 (Jul 9 2024); NRC fusion machines rule proposed Feb 26 2026, not final | Apr 13 2023 NRC Commission direction (SRM-SECY-23-0001): regulate fusion under the byproduct material framework (10 CFR Part 30), NOT Part 50/52 (utilization facility). Written into the Atomic Energy Act by ADVANCE Act s.205 (signed Jul 9 2024). Proposed rule published Feb 26 2026 (91 FR 9476, comments closed May 27 2026); no final rule in the Federal Register as of Oct 28 2026; statutory deadline Dec 31 2027 | in progress | Light-touch framework; no NRC reactor license under Part 50/52 needed; state-level licensing handles radioactive material handling and worker safety. The single biggest US regulatory enabler for private commercial fusion (editorial view). |
United Kingdom | Health and Safety Executive (HSE) + Environment Agency (England), SEPA (Scotland), Natural Resources Wales; not the Office for Nuclear Regulation (ONR) | Existing HSE and environmental-regulator regime; Energy Act 2023 s.156 (nuclear site licence not required) | Jun 2022 UK government response to consultation: fusion facilities are not nuclear installations under the Nuclear Installations Act 1965 and stay with existing regulators. Energy Act 2023 s.156 (Royal Assent Oct 26 2023, in force Sep 10 2024) adds that a fusion energy facility needs no nuclear site licence | in force | Fusion operators need no ONR nuclear site licence; HSE oversees workplace and radiological safety and the environmental regulator oversees radioactive substances and waste |
Japan | Nuclear Regulation Authority (NRA) under the RI Act; strategy set by the Cabinet Office (Integrated Innovation Strategy Promotion Council) | RI Act (Act on the Regulation of Radioisotopes etc.) for the time being; Fusion Energy Innovation Strategy (Cabinet Office, Apr 14 2023, revised Jun 4 2025) | Mar 25 2025 Cabinet Office expert panel paper on safety assurance for fusion energy: fusion devices fall outside the reactor regulation law; new devices of existing-device risk stay under the RI Act (radiation protection) for now, with the legal framework for pilot plants and DEMO to be studied later | in progress | JT-60SA (QST) and LHD (NIFS) are regulated under the RI Act as plasma generating devices, a type of radiation generator; no fusion-specific law yet |
European Union | Member-state-specific (no harmonized framework) | No harmonized EU fusion framework | No EU-level fusion regulatory framework. The Commission's call for evidence (Jun 3 to Jul 1 2025) lists an enabling regulatory framework for fusion facilities among the aims of the first EU Fusion Strategy, which the Commission's fusion page still lists as planned for 2026 | in progress | Germany: the federal cabinet's Oct 1 2025 action plan says the government intends to add explicit fusion rules to the Radiation Protection Act (BMFTR). ITER (Cadarache, France) is a basic nuclear installation overseen by the French nuclear safety authority (ASN, now ASNR). Not confirmed in a primary source as of 2026-10-28: national approaches in France and Italy. |
Canada | Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission (CNSC) | Nuclear Safety and Control Act; small fusion R&D facilities are licensed under the Class II Nuclear Facilities and Prescribed Equipment Regulations | CNSC position paper (modified Sep 19 2024): fusion facilities fall under the Nuclear Safety and Control Act and will be regulated on a risk-informed basis, differently from fission. Discussion paper DIS-25-01 on a conceptual fusion framework: consultation Jun 5 to Aug 4 2025 (closed) | in force | CNSC says it will enhance the framework in proportion to fusion risk. The Class II licence status of General Fusion's LM26 and the comparison with US Part 30: Not confirmed in a primary source as of 2026-10-28. |
South Korea | Nuclear Safety and Security Commission (NSSC); Ministry of Science and ICT (MSIT) sets fusion policy | State-led research framework | Jul 22 2024: MSIT's 20th National Fusion Committee adopted the Fusion Energy Realization Acceleration Strategy, which includes a dedicated body to develop a fusion regulatory framework separate from nuclear power. No fusion-specific law confirmed in a primary source as of 2026-10-28 | state-led | State-led; the 2024 strategy adds a KRW 1.2 trillion public-private development project and a startup programme |
China | National Nuclear Safety Administration (NNSA) / China Atomic Energy Authority (CAEA) | Atomic Energy Law (adopted Sep 12 2025, effective Jan 15 2026); state-led | Atomic Energy Law names fusion: Art. 14 (state encourages and supports R&D on controlled thermonuclear fusion) and Art. 39 (state to build a supervision system suited to fusion, with graded and classified management of fusion fuel and devices) | state-led | Detailed fusion supervision rules under Art. 39: Not confirmed in a primary source as of 2026-10-28. Research permissions held by Energy Singularity and ENN Group: Not confirmed in a primary source as of 2026-10-28. |
India | Atomic Energy Regulatory Board (AERB) + Department of Atomic Energy (DAE) | State-led; no commercial private fusion framework | n/a; India is ITER member, fusion treated as research | state-led | No private commercial fusion development |
Australia | Australian Radiation Protection and Nuclear Safety Agency (ARPANSA) | Framework TBD | The ARPANS Act 1998 and EPBC Act 1999 prohibit nuclear fuel fabrication plants, nuclear power plants, enrichment plants and reprocessing facilities; fusion is not named in those lists (Parliamentary Library); fusion's legal status is unresolved | ambiguous | HB11 Energy research permissions and the need for legal clarification: Not confirmed in a primary source as of 2026-10-28. |
Russia | Rostechnadzor | State-led; sanctions limit Western participation | n/a | state-led | Russia retains ITER membership; sanctioned Western commercial engagement limited |
Fusion FOAK Timeline
First-of-a-kind commercial-operation targets for 16 private fusion developers, comparing company-stated years against a Sterling estimate (not company-reported) of the plausible year.
Disputed timelines
3 of 16
FIA survey by 2035
70%
FIA survey by end of 2030s
89%
Fusion PPA Pipeline
Confirmed commercial fusion offtake deals. Microsoft + Helion, Google + CFS and Eni + CFS are the power purchase agreements; the rest are MoUs, LOIs, or collaboration agreements.
3 power purchase agreements in fusion. Microsoft + Helion (May 10 2023, 50 MW Washington State, 2028 target), Google + CFS (Jun 30 2025, 200 MW ARC Virginia plant, early 2030s) and Eni + CFS (Sep 22 2025, ARC Virginia plant, early 2030s) are the three fusion power purchase agreements, all listed below. TVA + Type One is an MoU on site-host with no offtake. Nucor + Helion is a collaboration agreement with a Nucor investment in Helion. Press coverage frequently miscites MoU + LOI as PPA. Verify any new claims before treating as binding.
ENI
Commonwealth Fusion Systems
MW n/a
2025-09-22
- Technology
- MCF tokamak HTS
- Binding PPA
- yes
- Target start
- early 2030s
Commonwealth Fusion Systems
200 MW
2025-06-30
- Technology
- MCF tokamak HTS
- Binding PPA
- yes
- Target start
- early 2030s
Nucor Corporation
Helion Energy
500 MW
2023-09-27
- Technology
- FRC, D-He3
- Binding PPA
- no
- Target start
- 2030 target
TVA (Tennessee Valley Authority)
Type One Energy
MW n/a
2023-05-15
- Technology
- MCF stellarator
- Binding PPA
- no
- Target start
- early 2030s
Constellation Energy
Helion Energy
MW n/a
2023-05-10
- Technology
- FRC, D-He3
- Binding PPA
- no
- Target start
- 2028 target with Microsoft PPA
Fusion Bull vs Bear Synthesis
Bull vs bear case across ten fusion dimensions plus four critical unknowns. Editor view: 2030 commercial fusion is unlikely, 2035 possible, 2040 to 2045 more credible.
Editor synthesis. The fusion bull case is real but fragile. Scientific feasibility is largely demonstrated. Capital is flowing. Regulatory framework is favorable in US/UK/Japan. The bear case concentrates on engineering tractability of Q_wall-plug > 1, closed tritium cycle, ICF shot rate, and the gap between research-Q and commercial-Q. Editor judgment: commercial fusion electricity to grid in any form by 2030 is highly unlikely; by 2035 is possible but not likely; by 2040-2045 is more credible. The single highest-leverage development would be a demonstration of Q_wall-plug > 1 in any private machine.
Scientific feasibility
Bull case
NIF achieved ignition (Q_laser > 1) Dec 5 2022 with 3.15 MJ from 2.05 MJ laser. JET DT-2 set 59 MJ over 5s record Feb 2022. EAST 403s steady plasma Apr 2023. KSTAR 100 M-degree C / 30s. ST40 100 M-degree C in compact spherical. Helion Trenta 100 M-degree C FRC. All key physics thresholds have been crossed in some configuration.
Bear case
NIF Q_wall-plug ~0.01 (laser wall-plug efficiency ~1 percent). JET Q_thermal 0.67 maximum. ITER Start of Research Operation set for 2034 (and DT for 2039) in Baseline 2024, vs First Plasma in Dec 2025 in the 2016 baseline. No machine has demonstrated Q_thermal > 1 sustained. Aneutronic fuels (p-B11, D-He3) untested for net energy.
Inflection to watch
First sustained Q_thermal > 1 in any machine (SPARC target 2027, ITER DT 2039) is the next major threshold.
HTS magnet readiness
Bull case
CFS SPARC TFMC achieved 20 T peak field Sep 2021 at fusion-relevant scale. Tokamak Energy ST40 records. Energy Singularity HH70 first plasma Jun 2024 (second private HTS tokamak). Type One Energy + Proxima Fusion + Realta Fusion scaling. HTS path unlocked compact-scale fusion: SPARC at 1.85 m major radius vs ITER 6.2 m.
Bear case
HTS tape supply chain is constrained. No commercial-scale (40+ T sustained) fusion magnet built. ReBCO tape cost still $50-100/kA-m vs target $25/kA-m. ITER uses Nb3Sn low-temperature superconductors at 11.8 T peak; HTS extrapolation untested at scale.
Inflection to watch
SPARC full magnet integration (2026-2027) and first plasma; Tokamak Energy Demo4 magnet learning feeding STEP Fusion (Sep 2026).
Tritium supply
Bull case
Lithium blanket breeding (Li-6 + n -> T + He) is being engineered into ARC + DEMO designs. ITER will trial breeding blanket modules. Helion D-He3 path eliminates tritium requirement entirely (uses D-D and harvests He-3 from D-D reactions). HB11 and TAE pursue p-B11 aneutronic path.
Bear case
Global commercial tritium supply ~3 kg/yr (mostly from CANDU heavy water plants). A 1 GWe D-T fusion plant needs ~150 kg/yr tritium. Closed-cycle tritium breeding at scale never demonstrated. Tritium permeates metals; recovery efficiency from blanket is unproven. Aneutronic fuels need temperatures 5-10x higher than D-T.
Inflection to watch
ITER breeding blanket trial results (~2040s). First credible closed-cycle tritium demo at scale would change the bear case.
critical unknowns4 open questions
When (if ever) does any machine demonstrate sustained Q_wall-plug > 1?
Why it matters: Q_laser > 1 (NIF) and Q_thermal targets at JET/ITER are both compatible with Q_wall-plug ~0.01. Commercial fusion requires Q_wall-plug > ~3. No public timeline targets Q_wall-plug > 1 before mid-2030s, and no roadmap demonstrates the path is engineering-tractable.
Earliest resolution: 2028 if Helion delivers Polaris electricity demo; 2032+ if Helion slips and CFS's ARC plant at Q_thermal > 1 doesn't have favorable wall-plug economics; 2040+ if ITER-class is the path.
Can closed-cycle tritium breeding be demonstrated at scale?
Why it matters: D-T fusion needs ~150 kg/yr tritium per GWe; global commercial supply is ~3 kg/yr. No breeding blanket has run at scale. Failure here forces aneutronic-only path or makes commercial D-T uneconomic.
Earliest resolution: ITER breeding blanket modules trial 2040s+. Private developer breeding tests (CFS ARC, UK STEP) earlier but at smaller scale.